Recipes

FrostedSandwichLoaf_1920

’50s Frosted Sandwich Loaf

Earning of pride-of-place on many a '40s and '50s shower table, the frosted sandwich loaf was a tower of cream-cheese ...
Read More
AnchoBraisedLambShank1920x1350

Ancho-Braised Lamb Shanks

This is one of those “low & slow” cooked dishes that’s perfect to start in the morning on a chilly ...
Read More
Ben_carrot

Ann Sather’s Carrot Bread

In 1945, Ann Sather plunked down savings earned at a meat-packing plant to buy an already-existing Swedish diner. Although of ...
Read More
Benapplecake_1920x1250

Apple Cake (Gina’s Hubba Hubba Apple Cake)

Gina DePalma thinks her mom got the recipe for this gorgeous, not-too-sweet apple cake from a ’50s women’s magazine. When ...
Read More
lambstew5forweb

Ballymaloe House Lamb Stew

Cherished recipes are like ripples, each one an echo of the original wave-making stone that broke the surface. This Ballymaloe ...
Read More
BanoffeePiePhoto

Banoffee (Banana Toffee Coffee) Tarts

This recipe story moves from Chicago to England to California and back again : ) It started back when I ...
Read More
BeefBourguignon_1920x1400_72

Beef Bourguignon

On blustery Midwestern days, my thoughts turn to the warm comforts of stews cooked with wine. More specifically? Beef Bourguignon ...
Read More
BiscuitCountryHam_1920x1280_72

Biscuits with Country Ham

Pull these soft little clouds of biscuit hot from the oven, slit them and fill them with salty country ham, ...
Read More
BeetsforBorschtFavorite_1920x1325

Borscht (Beet & Beef Soup)

I have a friend who calls beets "essence of dirt clod" : ) But I have always loved their earthy ...
Read More
BakedBeans&cornryewheatbread_1920x1350

Boston Baked Beans & Brown Bread

Despite the unfortunate Phaseolus vulgaris moniker—the American Common Bean category includes bunches of beloved, native-to-the-Americas beans: navy, red kidney, pinto, ...
Read More
brooklyn-blackout-cake-450

Brooklyn Blackout Cake

From the time it opened in its first unit in 1898 until the last Ebinger's Bakery turned out its lights ...
Read More
CobbSalad_1920x1380_72

Brown Derby Cobb Salad

From Hollywood’s Brown Derby restaurant and named for its owner, Robert Howard Cobb, the Cobb Salad is the original chopped ...
Read More
BenShrimpBebop1920

Buttermilk Fried Shrimp with Chipotle-Lime

A bunch of Chicagoans wrote to tell us they missed this spicy-good signature shrimp appetizer from long closed Joe’s Be-Bop ...
Read More
brownieuseforweb

Can o’ Hershey’s Brownies with Chocolate Frosting

Nevadan Elizabeth Castle says she got this recipe from her 93-year-old aunt, Myrnie Dawson, of Princeton, IL. Elizabeth got so ...
Read More
StickyBunsUse1920

Caramel Pecan Sticky Buns

In a typical day, Shelby McCreedy might deal with, oh, money laundering, public indecency, intoxication, and some kind of theft ...
Read More
littlejacksuse

Cheesecake Like Little Jack’s

From the time it opened in 1905, until it closed in 1962, Little Jack’s restaurant was a force in the ...
Read More
chilimacforweb2

Chicago Chili Mac

Ask about the origins of this belly-filling, budget-stretching American favorite and you’ll get different answers. Some point to Cincinnati’s habit ...
Read More
marrowdumplingsoup

Chicken Consomme with Marrow Dumplings

While the chicken soup I grew up with was a hearty rustic version, friends of mine have sung the praises ...
Read More
liverpate2450

Chicken Liver & Bacon Pate

After my brother got mononucleosis as a kindergartner (how does that happen to a five-year-old?) Mom launched a relentless iron-rich ...
Read More
coffeemolassesuse

Coffee & Molasses Dream Bars

Richly flavored with molasses, strong coffee and a generous portion of ground cloves, these bars are one of my favorite ...
Read More
ComoWhitefishOreganato_1920x1080_72

Como Inn Whitefish with Basil, Tomato & Oregano

I get a lot of requests for old recipes from the Como Inn, a long-gone Chicago restaurant favorite which operated ...
Read More
grape1920x1350

Concord Grape Tart & Pie

My lovely friend Kathleen S. grew up 15 miles from Silver Creek, NY, where they still host a Festival of ...
Read More
LRFConeyDogs_EATPigsinSpace-1920_72

Coney Island Chili Dogs

In Southeastern Michigan, “Coney Island” refers to 24-hour diners, and, the specific kind of chili-topped, grilled hot-dogs those diners serve ...
Read More
CornDogsLowRes2

Corn Dogs

Here's a little-known fact: Early corn-dog purveyor Ed Waldmire, Jr., wanted to call his corn-dog stand “The Crusty Cur”….his wife ...
Read More
CountryCaptain_1920x1080

Country Captain

Even though Georgia’s “official” state food is grits, there was a time when this simple tomato-and-pepper chicken curry was identified ...
Read More
NewCityCrawfishMonica1_Analogue_1920_72

Crawfish Boil & Crawfish Monica

Alfredo Nogueira can't remember the first time he ate crawfish. "But I'm sure I was really little," says the chef, ...
Read More
creamy-nectarine-y-cheesecake-2-450

Creamy Nectarine-y Cheesecake

Creamy cool and sunny as the summer nectarines it includes, this light, fruit-flecked cheesecake was requested by reader Marge. Marge ...
Read More
DresselsHorizontal1920_72

Dressel’s Chocolate Fudge Whipped Cream Cake

This beautiful cake is our family-birthday must. After I researched this story about it and developed the recipe, with input ...
Read More
Duck&AndouilleGumbo1920x1280

Duck & Andouille Gumbo

There are nearly as many recipes for gumbo as there are Cajuns. A lot of ‘em are made with okra, ...
Read More
empanadaspicadillo1

Empanadas Picadillo

This recipe search started with a request from a reader looking for a meat filling that included raisins, spices and ...
Read More
Evan-Moses-Chocolate-Malted-Frosty-Ice-Cream-450

Evan Moses’ 1940’s-Recipe Chocolate Malted “Frosty” Ice Cream

If you ever get to Benkelman, Nebraska, stop in at the Dundy County History Museum and tell them Lost Recipes ...
Read More
FigsOnMetalRule_Ready_1920

Fig Preserves & Fig Cake

It probably wasn’t an apple. Apricot, pear or pomegranate…maybe. But mythologists suggest that the eye-opening, original-sin-ushering fruit Eve plucked from ...
Read More
sloppyjoe21

Franklin Park BBQ Day Sloppy Joes

PTA School Barbecue Day has been a beloved tradition at Franklin Park, IL, District 84 schools since the 1950s. Featuring ...
Read More
1920fritzelsblueberryhoriz

Fritzel’s Griddle Cakes with Cherry Berry Sauce

There are a lot of vintage cheesecake recipes out there that ask you to “sieve” cottage cheese. Basically, that means ...
Read More
1920Fritzel's PSteak2USE

Fritzel’s Pepper Steak

I first launched Lost Recipes Found as a column in the Chicago Tribune, which has a lovely archive of vintage ...
Read More
BenGermanChocCake1920

German Chocolate Cake (Marshall Field’s)

It’s tall. It’s magnificent. It’s the quintessential German Chocolate Cake: Four layers with classic coconut pecan filling. This cake’s tender ...
Read More
CinnamonFrosted

Giant Cinnamon Rolls

This goes back to when I first launched Lost Recipes Found for the Chicago Tribune, in answer to a reader ...
Read More
glutenfreecinnamon_1920_saturated_brighter

Gluten-Free Cinnamon Rolls

America's love affair with cinnamon rolls is alive and well. Cinnamon rolls, sticky buns, coffee cakes...I've featured recipes for all ...
Read More
apricot450

Grandma Bertha’s Apricot Delights

Although there’s not much razzle dazzle on the outside, beauty–delicate, buttery, apricot-tender, cinnamon-sugared perfection–lies within. Susan Levin of Long Grove, ...
Read More
GrandmasSupper_1920x1380_72

Grandma’s Sunday Supper (Chicken Fricassee with Vegetables & Light Slaw)

When I grew up in 1970s Chicago, Sundays were family days. We’d drive to Grandma’s little brick bungalow on the ...
Read More
Green-Goddess-Chip-Dip-450

Green Goddess Dip

Anchovies, chives, parsley, wine vinegar, sour cream…the original Green Goddess dressing was created by Chef Phillip Roemer of San Francisco’s ...
Read More
Figbarsforweb

Homemade Fig Bars

There are lots of new takes on “newtons” out there. Our vintage version riffs on Ann Pillsbury’s classic ’50s recipe ...
Read More
fritopieforweb2

Hoosier Mama’s Frito-Chili Pie

Born and schooled in Texas, I ate traditional Frito-Chili Pie with the best of them (aka bag-o-corn-chips with chili ladled ...
Read More
Ben1920SpinachBeautiful_cropped

Jalapeno Creamed Spinach

Creamed spinach–Texas style! Sans canned-creamed-soup and minus the processed cheese, this is a gourmet side dish worthy of birthday dinners ...
Read More
figjamtartforweb-e1434687407619

Jam Tart (or, Best Basic Bar Cookies)

The bar cookie brings with it the promise of plenty, the memory of family gatherings where people talked long and ...
Read More
Jordan-Marsh-Blueberry-Muffin-450

Jordan Marsh Blueberry Muffins

I first ran this recipe story four years ago, when the Chicago Tribune gave me permission to take the Lost ...
Read More
BenDerbypie_1920x1080_72

Kentucky Derby Chocolate Pecan Pie

Was Derby pie named for the hat or the horse race? The horse race. But a hat does figure in ...
Read More
1920KeyLimePie_1920x1250_72

Key Lime Pie

The story of Key lime pie is delightfully odd, including Cuban sponge "hookers", mystery aunts, canned milk and curing. The ...
Read More
kirkdouglasfavoritemeatloaf_hires_10

Kirk Douglas’ Favorite Meatloaf

Loved chatting with Monica Eng about finding vintage recipes for her podcast with Louisa Chu--listen to the segment here (the ...
Read More
LimePie2450

Lime-Chocolate Ice Cream Pie

Serendipity! Two or three people who don’t know each other, and live hundreds of miles apart in separate States, ask ...
Read More
raspberrybars

Lutz’s Raspberry Nut Bars

One of Chicago’s most famous pastry chefs until his death in 2011, Lutz Olkiewicz was sweets master at the Drake ...
Read More
guerrillacookies1sharper_10

Madison Guerrilla Cookie (….or comes close!)

I just had a great conversation with Monica Eng of WBEZ about how people's recollections of recipes they loved, but ...
Read More
marshall-fields-chinese-chews-450

Marshall Field’s Chinese Chews

I would never have thought to put dates with chocolate. But wow! So good! The result, as exemplified in this ...
Read More
MeltingAppleCake1920x1250

Melting Apple Cake

Baking recipes usually frown on softer apples, specifying instead that you use granny smith. That means you end up making ...
Read More
StrawberryPie_1920x1280_72

Mile-High Strawberry Pie

Max Hess, Jr. was the P.T. Barnum of the department store world, a master at selling with flamboyance and showmanship ...
Read More
GiardinieraBEST450

New Orleans Okra Giardiniera

When Liz Williams, director of New Orleans’ Southern Food & Beverage Museum was little, her mama couldn't stand okra. "So, ...
Read More
old-fashioned-sugar-cookie-450

Old-fashioned Butter Cookies

When I was growing up, our sometime babysitter Shirley loved baking. I can still see her, arms crossed behind her ...
Read More
jo-ryman-scotts-orange-delight-cookies-450

Orange Dips

In 1961, these light, fresh-orange-and-sugar-glazed, tea cookies won Scott the first-ever bake-off at Fairbanks, Alaska’s Tanana Valley State Fair, making ...
Read More
persimmoncake_hires_3use

Persimmon Spice Cake with Caramel Frosting

For anybody unfamiliar, persimmons are native to America, highly-nutritious and once prized by American Indians and early settlers. They also ...
Read More
PimientoCheeseCherryBombsLowresUSE

Pimiento Cheese Cherry Bombs

My mom loved pimiento cheese. She had an old box grater and used to make me shred mounds of cheddar ...
Read More
PreservedLemonGOOD

Preserved Meyer Lemons

Preserving lemons in salt is an ancient practice with delicious results. I am crazed for these, eating them sliced and ...
Read More
sauerkraut-soup-450

Sauerkraut Soup

We've had requesters looking for what to do with the leftover sauerkraut, so this one's for you! Rich with butter, ...
Read More
savory-sage-sausage-dressing-450

Sausage & Sage Stuffing

The scent of toasting bread cubes, sausage in the skillet and fresh snipped sage just make Thanksgiving morning what it ...
Read More
scotcheggsbetter

Scotch Eggs

So a little history…Go to the website for British gourmet food retailer Fortnum & Mason and you’ll find the claim ...
Read More
BenSweetPotatoes5x5_300

Senator Russell’s Sweet Potato Casserole

Calling down to Georgia’s State Capitol offices and the Culinary History Society of Georgia, nobody could comment on the gustatorial ...
Read More
SSPieForWebUse

Serviceberry Pie (Yes, you can eat them!)

The berry world has its less-than-romantic nomenclature. I mean, “straw” or “rasp” don’t scream, “Eat me!” But those berries eclipsed ...
Read More
ShakerLemonUse

Shaker Lemon Pie

Except for the no-sex and separation-from-the-world rules (pretty hard to overlook), I admire most everything I’ve read about Shakers. Progressive ...
Read More
mushroomloaf_1920x1350_72

Sherried Crimini & Walnut Loaf

I once lived in a big, ugly green co-op house in South Evanston, where vegetarian was how you cooked, if ...
Read More
BlackPigStroganoff_1920x1350

Short Rib Stroganoff

There was a time when company coming meant Rob Hurrie's mom whipped up the 2-cans-of-condensed-soup-ground-beef-bacon-&sour-cream stroganoff. Chef Rob Hurrie’s deeply-flavorful ...
Read More
sweetpotatoprep5-5-x-3-7

Spiced Butternut Squash Pie & Southern Sweet Potato Pie

Ever since a food blogger published an article early this fall talking about her shock and horror at discovering that ...
Read More
StrawberriesWadmalaw_1920_72

Strawberries & Cream Fridge Cake

Dreamy, chilled desserts full of cream, marshmallow, or mousse were very popular with housewives of the forties and fifties when ...
Read More
StrawberriesinaCloudRectangle1920

Strawberries in a Cloud (Blitz Torte)

I am a strawberry girl. I eat strawberries out of hand, make pies & jams with them, macerate them, even ...
Read More
SummerGirl

Summer Girl Soda

Still hot? Me too! How about this vintage soda fountain creation? Raspberry, orange and vanilla in frothy foam…with all those ...
Read More
sister-marys-corn-relish-2-450

Summer! Sister Mary’s Corn Relish

This is the corn relish recipe that has won self-professed “ribbon slut” Barb Schaller eight blue ribbons at the Minnesota ...
Read More
1920_72_SunchokePotatoSunchokeArtichokeHorizontal

Sunchokes Two Ways: Soup & Smashed Potato

Earthy, sexy, silky, sunchokes beguile. To me, they’re like truffles in their scent and ability to make you crave just ...
Read More
1920SwedishhorizontalUSETHIS

Swedish Beet, Potato & Lettuce Salad with Mustard Cream

Really simple, really good, really pretty: just chilled red potatoes, beets, crisp lettuce and a creamy, sweet & tangy mustard ...
Read More
CornPie450x450

Sweetcorn & Bacon Pie

The waitress at Ernie Risser’s family restaurant in Womelsdorf, PA, watches me looking dubiously at the gravy she just plunked ...
Read More
1920texaschileconcarne

Texas Chili Con Carne

Pennie F. wrote in search of an old recipe for “beanless” chili that was her family's Sunday staple 20 years ...
Read More
palmerhousechocfudgebrownielowres

The Original Chocolate Fudge Brownie (Palmer House)

The Chicago World’s Columbian Exposition of 1893 was a chocolate-lovers dream: Boston-based chocolatier Walter M. Lowney brought the first American ...
Read More
TongaToast_1920x1080_72

Tonga Toast (Banana-Stuffed French Toast with Strawberries)

Since debuting in 1971 at Disney’s Polynesian Resort, Tonga Toast–a cinnamon-sugared chunk of deep-fried, banana-stuffed breakfast bliss–has always been a ...
Read More
VealStroganoff_1920X1280_72

Veal Stroganoff

When Count Pavel Alexandrovich Stroganov wasn’t busy commanding the Russian infantry in Napoleonic Wars, he feasted. Historians suggest that an ...
Read More
very-airy-no-bake-cheesecake-450

Very Airy No-Bake Cheesecake

Cheesecakes come in dozens of flavors and textures. Contrasting with the dense, baked cheesecakes many know, this vintage 1959 no-bake ...
Read More
whitehallcreamedspinach1use

Whitehall Club Creamed Spinach

Established as a private-dining club in Chicago’s boutique Whitehall Hotel in 1956, The Whitehall Club was a fine-dining fixture for ...
Read More
peartart

Wine-Poached Pear & Rosemary Tart

I so love the flavor of our wine-poached pears with a little cheese, it made me imagine them in this ...
Read More
poachedpearsforweb

Wine-Poached Pears

As far back as the 15th century, English cooks discovered that wine-poaching hard pears made them both tender and palatable ...
Read More
zucchini-relish-450

Zucchini Relish

Like bread & butter pickles? Then you’ll like the taste of this relish. I’ve received requests for what to do ...
Read More
redstarzweibeluse

Zwiebelfleisch (Red Star Inn)

The road to recreating lost recipes can be winding–not always leading where you expected it to go. The search for ...
Read More